Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 2,761 through 2,775 (of 2,806 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Ni Wa particle combination #22318

    Joel
    Member

    It’s called double particles – they don’t combine, they’re just performing separate functions. The に is marking 私たち as (I think) the indirect object of the sentence, while the は is marking it as the topic. To be honest, I’m not entirely sure what the に is doing in that sentence, but to give another example:

    ここでは友達と会います。

    This basically translates as “Here is where I am meeting my friend.” The で is still marking ここ as the location, while the は also marks it as the subject.

    in reply to: Seasons are broken up into ??? #22317

    Joel
    Member

    Yah. Pages assemble to form chapters, which assemble to form seasons.

    in reply to: Real Life Kanji Learning #22284

    Joel
    Member

    An interesting idea – quite practical, too. I remember when I was in Japan with nothing but my phrasebook to help me decipher the options on the hotel’s coin-operated washing machine…

    in reply to: How can you have 2 "は" in one sentence #22277

    Joel
    Member

    My best guess is this. I’m not entirely certain, to be honest – like you, I’ve only done N5. It seems to me what they’re saying is that the first は kind of implies a separate clause in which the second は is acting as a contrastive marker rather than the topic marker. Something like “on the subject of today’s weather: the outside (as opposed to inside) is very hot, but inside the house (as opposed to outside) is nice and cool.”

    「今日の天気は」 may be used once for the purpose of separating into two.
    「今日の天気は」「外はとても暑いのに家の中は涼しいです」 < — this is the sentence split into two pieces
    It’s like Erika-san’s correction, if you add a comma, you can understand it more easily, perhaps.

    Edit: The same applies to the sentence in the first post as well, I guess, though I’m still not clear on why “here” is being contrasted with “today” since the joining word is “because” not “but”. Maybe I’m just trying to make my English grammar work in Japanese…

    • This reply was modified 13 years ago by  Joel.
    in reply to: katakana help #22276

    Joel
    Member

    Yeah, I was a bit puzzled by that lesson as well – Koichi even makes a specific point of saying “トゥ isn’t used that much because it’s pronounced the same as と”‘ to which my first thought was “…so why would they have it?” Methinks Koichi might be a little confused here. It’s not until you posted this thread that I actually thought of looking for examples where it’s commonly used, so thanks for that, Jesse. =)

    in reply to: How can you have 2 "は" in one sentence #22274

    Joel
    Member

    Ask them to clarify and post the clarification here? Because I really don’t get why 今はここは is correct. Another user further down the page has suggested こちらは今冬で which also works, and doesn’t have two はs (thought I do wonder about こちら in this context).

    I do, incidentally, agree with using なので in place of でしかし =P

    in reply to: How can you have 2 "は" in one sentence #22267

    Joel
    Member

    Ah, I didn’t see that – my mistake. Yeah, that looks wrong. It should probably be 今、ここは or 今はここで depending on whether you wanted the emphasis to be on “now” or “here”.

    I don’t really know quite how Lang-8 works – are they native speakers? If they are, it feels a bit silly for me to be going “pah, what do they know?”… Do you have a link for this sentence?

    in reply to: Does this make sense? #22266

    Joel
    Member

    Also, for a slight variation in subtext: 日本語をならうのはたのしいです – learning Japanese is fun

    in reply to: katakana help #22265

    Joel
    Member

    It’s pronounced “tu” – it’s needed because the katakana t+u sound is pronounced “tsu”. For example, Tomorrowland, an area in the Tokyo Disneyland, it written as トゥモローランド in katakana.

    As with all the small-vowel katakana combinations, it’s pronounced by replacing the vowel sound of the big one with the small one – it’s different to the kana glides. So トゥ is “to” with a “u” in place of the “o” to make “tu”, フェ, is “fu” with an “e” in place of the “u” to make “fe”, et cetera.

    in reply to: Learning to write kanji #22251

    Joel
    Member

    Personally, I rather like writing kanji. I can write a sentence on a piece of paper, then immediately look back at it and go “hey, I just wrote that. Wow” =)

    in reply to: How can you have 2 "は" in one sentence #22250

    Joel
    Member

    As well as being the topic marker, は is also a contrastive marker – that is, it marks two things being contrasted with each other. For example, “summer is hot, but winter is cold” would be 夏暑いですが、冬寒いです – it’s contrasting summer, which is hot, with winter, which is cold.

    However, your sentence is a because sentence, not a but. I guess you can kind of see it as contrasting today with now, but to me it seems kinda weird. Surely the first は should be a が…

    in reply to: JLPT in 2 weeks #22000

    Joel
    Member

    Oh hey, it’s on twice a year in New Zealand but not Australia. Feeling kinda shafted now. Not that I was actually planning to do it in July, though…

    in reply to: Learn these later kanji vocab #21996

    Joel
    Member

    The general idea is that the words are used reasonably commonly, but you haven’t learnt the kanji yet, because it has more strokes. He’s giving examples of words where the current kanji you’re learning is used so that you can come to recognise it, but you (probably) won’t be able to fully read it until you’ve learnt the other kanji at a later stage.

    in reply to: I give up. #21995

    Joel
    Member

    Don’t believe in yourself. Believe in the me that believes in you. =)

    in reply to: JLPT in 2 weeks #21990

    Joel
    Member

    Michael wrote:
    > But if you told people just now, right here, how would they know?

    You never know who here might be some sort of Japan Foundation stooge. *Eyes people suspiciously*

    Dennis wrote:
    > Joel, you’re right – the JLPT is given in July only in Japan.

    Yeah, so many people in this thread have mentioned their plans to do it in July that I was starting wonder if I was misinformed, or just plain crazy…

Viewing 15 posts - 2,761 through 2,775 (of 2,806 total)